Heat pumps

COP falls when the weather's colder. Is COP 5 achievable in the winter, when demand is greatest? Just asking, I don't know much about heat pumps, apart from the operating principle.
This is a tricky question.

You need to start with a basis in physics, forget about degrees C, which is limited by your human experience and think in terms of absolute temperature.

The Kelvin scale is an absolute temperature scale where differences like -3°C (270.15 K) to 20°C (293.15 K) are relatively small (only around 8% difference).

So by the physics the task is easier, lots of energy around at -3C.

Heat pumps utilize refrigerants, and the choice of refrigerant has a large impact on the COP. But, safety constraints and reasonable operating pressures limit the selection of high pressure, high-performance refrigerants in this application. (Larger industrial systems often use ammonia for instance - which would not be advisable in a domestic install. It's also why those mini fridges use propane or butane, amazing choices but in large volumes... More risky).

To a certain extent the economics of the pump also effect this choice. (simplicity, number of moving parts etc). Einstein famously jointly developed a constant pressure zero moving part refrigerator with Szilard that will be popular soon.

Despite these limitations, modern heat pump systems, maintain COP of around 3 even at -3°C, thanks to features like variable speed compressors and enhanced vapor injection. But when the air temp is a bit warmer, cop dramatically increases.

In most places in the UK they see very few cold days a year and we need to see a growing trend away from "guesstimates" and towards actual calculations - at the moment you *must* size your heat pump for the worst day of the year, despite that not being needed for 98% of the time - you also *cannot* factor in a secondary heat source - I expect as we move on this will change to a day per day system. This is compounded by a move to modulated heat and not bursts of unmodulated heat.

You can also extend building wide performance with things like variable refrigerant flow where you can pass heat from sun side of building to the other etc.
 
Sponsored Links
The Einstein-Szilard refrigeration system is interesting. It was developed with the intention to make domestic refrigeration safer. The question is could it be developed further to be able to pump the few kilowatts needed for heating a house.

google translated extract from an article on th eAutomatischer Beton-Volks-Kühlschrank = Automatic concrete people's refrigerator

http://www.presse.uni-oldenburg.de/f-aktuell/05-363.html

The new refrigeration unit had to meet the following requirements: do without an electricity supply, contain no moving parts for safety reasons and not work with a closed coolant circuit. Rather, the toxic coolant should be continuously removed from the living area without harming the occupants. Einstein and Szilard came up with two possible construction and functional principles for this: an electromagnetic pump for liquid metal and the evaporator/absorption principle with a water jet pump and alcohol as the coolant. Both principles were pushed forward to prototypes, in the case of the "automatic concrete people's refrigerator" from Citogel (Hamburg) even to production samples, which were exhibited at the Leipzig Trade Fair in 1928 and 1929.


The Smithsonian Institution have a recent article on the matter

 
You need to start with a basis in physics, forget about degrees C, which is limited by your human experience and think in terms of absolute temperature.

The Kelvin scale is an absolute temperature scale where differences like -3°C (270.15 K) to 20°C (293.15 K) are relatively small (only around 8% difference).
I should have said I have a degree in physics (from way back!) so I understand the basics, but you've clearly gone into it it much more detail.
 
Sponsored Links
This is a tricky question.

You need to start with a basis in physics, forget about degrees C, which is limited by your human experience and think in terms of absolute temperature.

The Kelvin scale is an absolute temperature scale where differences like -3°C (270.15 K) to 20°C (293.15 K) are relatively small (only around 8% difference).

Compressor pressure ratio in compressing a refrigerant gas like R32 from -3C to 45C is, 27.96/7.38, 3.79 and from 20C to 45C is, 27.96/14.74, 1.9. I don't know how proportionate the compressor power required is but would think a multiple of 8%
 
Yes as it's gets colder the heat pump has to work significantly harder, in line with a power law but most people can't even wrap their head around how we get heat "from" -3C air.
 

DIYnot Local

Staff member

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Back
Top