The Mother Of All Thumpings

[ReganAndCarter]

That is a good point.
However the Nobel prize is the creation of western Christian culture, so its natural that people who are born into that culture will also outperform cultures that have not been exposed to western thought.

Yes, that's logical, but there are millions more muslims living in The West than there are Jews in the whole world.

 

[Bod ...]

Taking land. Then taking some more. Then some more...

You haven't mentioned giving land

 

[Bod ...]

Yes, that's logical, but there are millions more muslims living in The West than there are Jews in the whole world.

And of course Jews are not Christian either.

 

[Brigadier]

When you see someone wandering around in a sheet and sandals in winter in Bristol in 2023, you have to be of the opinion that they're not cut out for 21st century life in a developed country.

Were they cross-climate sandals, R&C?

 

[Roy Bloom]

There's been 9 Muslim winners of the Nobel Peace prize, the latest in 2023.

ReganandCarter is blind to any success of Muslims.
He's full of blind hatred for them.
His posts just in this thread makes that obvious.

 

[Roy Bloom]

Extremeley over simplistic I realise, ..., we should keep our noses out and let them sort it out.

When South Africa was an apartheid regime, the UK ostracised it.
Israel is an apartheid regime and UK is supporting it's policies.
Double standards?

 

[Tarquintar]

Yes, that's logical, but there are millions more muslims living in The West than there are Jews in the whole world.

ReganandCarter is blind to any success of Muslims.
He's full of blind hatred for them.
His posts just in this thread makes that obvious.

I'll stand corrected but I think he was making the point that based on averages, there should be more Muslim Nobel Prize Winners?

 

[Roy Bloom]

If they where a special case. you would see Jews make up the panel of every MOTd . They would be on most TV adverts
There would be Jewish super Hero's. More and more Jewish TV presenters. You would be forgiven for thinking they made up half thr population of this country.

Every news program for the last 20 years there would be a story involving Jews. Our prisons would be full of Jewish inmates.

But non of the above is true.

What?
Your response has no releavance to your original claim:

Jews are living in fear in this country and have been in France for a very long time.

In reference to your claim, I asked:

So are Muslims. Why do you identify Jews as being a special case?
In reality I suspect that Jews, as a whole, suffer less discrimination than other groups.
Only a minority of Jews are identifiable as Jews. Ohther ethnicities are easily identifiable, immigrants or not.

Can you answer the question i asked, not just do another of your off-topic diatribes

What you said may well be true, but because the vast majority of Jews are not easily reconisable as Jews, your peculiar reference to Jews in general life may well be true. So none of your examples can be dismissed as 'not true'.
"Jews" do not even appear as category in the UK census data:

List of ethnic groups

Read about the 18 ethnic groups recommended for use by government when they ask for someone’s ethnicity in England and Wales.

www.ethnicity-facts-figures.service.gov.uk

 

[Roy Bloom]

I'll stand corrected but I think he was making the point that based on averages, there should be more Muslim Nobel Prize Winners?

His argument was based on some white (or Christian) superiority complex.

 

[Roy Bloom]

Another yardstick that's been mentioned before is to compare the number of Jewish Nobel Prize winners to muslims. Jews feature heavily, don't think there's even one muslim. Good barometer of the opposing religions' contribution to society. Some give, others take. Then take some more.

No doubt white actors are better than black actors according to your criteria.

 

[fillyboy]

No doubt white actors are better than black actors according to your criteria.

Oscars 2023: the full list of winners

All the winners and losers from the 95th Academy Awards

www.theguardian.com

 

[Roy Bloom]

There's been 9 Muslim winners of the Nobel Peace prize, the latest in 2023.

That's just for the Peace prize.
ReganandCrater didn't refer only to the Peace prize.

 

[Roy Bloom]

Oscars 2023: the full list of winners

All the winners and losers from the 95th Academy Awards

www.theguardian.com

That's as bad as Mottie's how many tomatoes in the Waitrose on the Essex High street, on Friday afternoon in last November, which were priced at 29p per kilo, and grown in Jersey.

 

[Roy Bloom]

Yes, that's logical, but there are millions more muslims living in The West than there are Jews in the whole world.

That's because you don't need to prove your lineage to be a Muslim.

 

[Roy Bloom]

And of course Jews are not Christian either.

You don't need to prove your lineage to be a Christian either.