What Mini Trip for new cooker

Joined
31 Jul 2009
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
Location
Staffordshire
Country
United Kingdom
Hello, my daughter has just got herself a house and has bought a new cooker rated at 9800w - 10700w, the cooker is going to be about 4metres from the 4 outlet consumer box which uses Wylex Type B Plug in Mini Trip Breakers.
The kitchen has been stripped out and there is already 6mm cable already there, I imagine it wants replacing with 10mm for this load, there is already a 40 amp mtb in place but is this ok to use with a cooker of this rating, if not what should i use
Thanks for any help
Phil
 
That 4-way Wylex shouldn't even have a 40A breaker in it, let alone anything bigger - boards with a main switch rated at less than 100A shouldn't be fitted with an MCB bigger than 32A.

Does it sit squarely in place, or does it look a bit wonky?

A 40A circuit will probably be OK for that cooker (does it have an induction hob with a boost facility? What do the instructions specify for the circuit?).

But as it shouldn't be there anyway, and as a 4-way Wylex is

a) inadequate these days

b) indicative of an installation of a certain age

I suggest getting it replaced, the installation checked etc - now would be a good time for any rewiring to take place, before redecorating etc.
 
how is the rating marked?
why 9800W - 10700W?
is that based on 220 - 240V?

it works out to 44A if it is..

6mm is good for 47A if it's clipped direct and not de-rated by things like insulation and such.. but to be on the safe side I'd go for 10mm and a 45A breaker. ( can't get those on wylex can you? )

time is good now for a new CU and a new kitchen circuit..
 
it works out to 44A if it is..
(44-10)x0.3+15=_____________

No - I don't much like it, but if it weren't for the fact that the circuit is wrong anyway, i.e. if it were a case of connecting it to a sound 40A circuit I'd say go for it, unless you're going to be rewiring anyway.
 
9800/220 = 44.54A
10700/240 = 44.58A

diversity doesn't apply to the cable, it applies to maximum demand of the installation.. ( 311.1 )

the cable must still be installed to take the maximum demand possible..

calculating it, if you don't put a socket on it you get 20.2A.. so are you happy then to wire a 10.7KW cooker in 2.5?

that calculation is also not found in the regs book, it's in the OSG.. which as you so like to point out to others is a guide..
 
Thanks for the quick replies but you have lost me a bit as you are all obviously experts in the subject
The cooker she has got herself is a Hotpoint C367EKH with a ceramic hob not induction
ban-all-sheds, If you mean do the circuit breakers look wonky, not really they seem to sit snugly
ColJack : we have not unpacked the cooker yet but on the outer packaging it says 9800W - 10700W and is based on 220 - 240v

You are right the box does need replacing, the previous owner had the house rewired and it has a digital meter beside the box, how long ago this was i dont know off hand but it was in the last few years, why they didnt change the box I dont know
I gather from what you are saying 40amp is the biggest breaker to be used in this box anyway
But meanwhile would it be safe to use if I changed the cable for 10mm, it will be just clipped to the wall, not buried and there will not be a socket on the cooker unit,
Thanks Phil
 
Another thought, would it be possible to take tails from the input supply to a seperate small correctly rated single fuse box just for the cooker to take the load off the main fuse box
 
Another thought, would it be possible to take tails from the input supply to a seperate small correctly rated single fuse box just for the cooker to take the load off the main fuse box
Rather than do that, have a full-sized CU put in, then it can be used to transfer existing and new circuits to, rather than install a mini-unit which can't be used for anything else. The cost difference would be marginal.


Thanks for the quick replies but you have lost me a bit as you are all obviously experts in the subject
Sorry - it was a chat about diversity.

If you look at your CU, you'll probably see more than one lighting circuit, more than one socket circuit etc. If you were to add up the ratings on all the MCBs it would come to far more than the rating of your supply fuse, which will be 60 - 100A.

The reason it doesn't blow is that you don't run all your circuits flat out - you don't have 1.4kW of lighting burning on each circuit, you don't have several fan heaters plugged into each socket circuit etc. The allowance for the fact that you don't do these things is called diversity, and there are guidelines on how this is worked out to come up with a reasonable estimate for your overall load.

A cooker is one appliance where diversity is applied - if you think about it, once the oven or grill or ring has reached the right temperature it switches off, and only clicks back in now and then for a short time to keep the temperature level. Electric cookers are not like gas, you can't run an element at a lower level, it is either on or it is off - no in-between.

So your 9.8kW - 10.7kW cooker doesn't use that continuously - it'll be rare to have every part in use at once, and even when you do it'll only consume all that power for a short while from cold.

The guideline for working out how much to allow for a cooker is the first 10A + 30% of the remainder, then +5A if the cooker control unit has a socket. So for a "45A" appliance that would be 10A + 10.5A + possibly 5A, i.e. 21-26A.

I have a lot of sympathy with Col's view that you shouldn't do that on a per-circuit basis, i.e. it's for working out the demand of your whole house, and that if you have a 45A appliance you should have it on a 45A circuit, but when I've expressed that view in the past I've often been shouted down and called some unpleasant names, and been accused of ripping people off etc.

As long as the relationship between cable capacity and MCB rating is OK, no harm can be done by connecting too large a load - all that would happen would be that the MCB would do its job and trip. If you were putting in a new circuit I'd say use 10mm² on a 45A breaker, but as you already have a 40A circuit I'd say give it a go first and see what happens in practice.

But....

I'm still not sure that is an OK 40A circuit. What is the rating of the main switch - does it say? Does it not say 100A?

Any chance of a photo?


ban-all-sheds, If you mean do the circuit breakers look wonky, not really they seem to sit snugly
The 40A one has a plastic tab on it to prevent it being used in boards which are not rated highly enough. I guess it could have been broken off..


You are right the box does need replacing, the previous owner had the house rewired and it has a digital meter beside the box, how long ago this was i dont know off hand but it was in the last few years, why they didnt change the box I dont know
It's not unknown for sellers to pretend to have rewired by just replacing the cables you can see.


I gather from what you are saying 40amp is the biggest breaker to be used in this box anyway
Or maybe less. Someone here once posted a photo of an old Wylex which had gone bad - not a pretty sight....


But meanwhile would it be safe to use if I changed the cable for 10mm, it will be just clipped to the wall, not buried and there will not be a socket on the cooker unit,
It's not the relationship of the 40A breaker to the 6mm² cable which is in doubt, it's the presence of that breaker in the CU. Changing to a 10mm² cable won't affect that.
 
i suppose if the last resident only had a low power older cooker this setup was ok, as you say you dont have everything turn on all the time, although i suppose at say christmas all the rings and the oven could be on together and then if a washing machine and dryer were being used on another circuit it all adds up.
I have replaced some of the light fitting sockets etc and it looks like it has all been rewired and in places in the loft and under the floors the old wiring was just cut and left in place but the question is has it been done proplerly as i would have thought they would have replaced the cu as well not just replace the old fuses with cbs
I will have a look at the cu and see if it says what rating it is although I think the best thing is to have it replaced, although meanwhile as you say if it did get overloaded hopefully it will just trip, but i would rather have her get it done properly for my peace of mind.
Thanks for all the help and advice and explaining the technical terms,
 
Here's an old Wylex overloaded with a high-rated shower.

BurntShowerCableII.jpg


Here's another: In this pic, the shower was on the 5A breaker (with 30A wire) but was overheating. To solve the problem, the "spark" connected it to the main tails instead...

wylexwith6mm.jpg


This one was a 60A Wylex running a 10.8kW shower on 30A 3036 fuse:

60AWylexvs10.jpg


And here's the fuse carrier & shield:

60AWylexvs10-1.jpg


And here's the piece de resistance:

A 30A CU running not one but 2 showers, an 8.5 and a 9.6kW, all on one 6mm² feed via a 30A 3036 again.

BurntOutWylexBoard.jpg
 
We are getting an electrician in to replace the fuse box, especially after looking at those picture.
Another question is refering to the other end of the cable, does the cooker isolation switch have to be in the wall or does it comply with regulations to have it inside the base unit beside the cooker, which would mean we didnt have to channel out the wall
Thanks
 
the jury is still out as to whether the switch is for isolation or for maintainence..
either way it has to visible..
so no.. you can't put it in a cupboard.
 

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Back
Top