A thread for discussing "when is a Transformer not a Transformer" (technical and semantic)

guinea pigs (the animal has a lower case letter), Guinea (the place has an upper case letter), so not the same.
You never cease to amaze us with the way that no matter how stupid and desperate you have already made yourself appear, you seem able to find ways to make yourself look even more stupid and desperate.

Capital letter or no there is a modifier before the word "pig". And they are not pigs.

There is a word before "pig" just like there are with the following:

Electrical world

Electronic cigarette

Electronic book

Electronic transformer​

You use the first, and you do not object to the 2nd or 3rd. Even though the world is not electrical, electronic cigarettes are not cigarettes and electronic books are not books.

But you are so incensed by the last one on the list that you are prepared to repeatedly tell lies about the existence of them.
 
Sponsored Links
People are ignorant of the way LED lighting operates and this is because the marketing industry is also ignorant and uses the wrong terminalogy.
No it is not, Bernard.

No.

It .

Is.

Not.


No matter how many times I have asked you, you have not once even tried to explain how people would suddenly know how LED lighting operates, or what the little plastic bricks do inside if only the little plastic bricks supplying the lighting were "correctly" named.

Not once.

Because you know you can't.


One major supplier is selling 12 volt fixed voltage "electronic transformers" as LED drivers. LED Drivers control current to suit the LED elements. What they are selling is a voltage source or power supply.
Do they, or do they not, drive the LEDs?

Whether they drive them by providing them with a constant voltage or drive them by providing a constant current they are still providing the power to drive them.


The devices labeled as "electronic transformers" are power supplies that may be designed to provide a constant voltage. ( power supply ) or a constant current ( LED driver )
Indeed.

And I (and you) have lost count of the number of people we get here who do not know what the difference is between voltage and current, who don't know that voltage can only be measured between two points. They don't know what either of them are, and they would not know what the difference was between a constant voltage power supply and a constant voltage one.

99% of these will have a transformer inside them along with a variable number of other components. These components create a high frequency chopped supply to the primary of the transformer which allows for the transformer to be a very small item.
Yes, we all know that.

And we all also know that that would continue to be the case no matter what label is stuck on the outside of the enclosure. The name does not affect what is inside.


So we have two basic types of "electronic transformer" but both are labelled as "electronic transformer". The first type supplies a constant voltage and the secnd type supplies a constant current. Some of the constant current type are known as LED drivers as that is what they are designed for. to drive a constant current through an LED element. Most LED lamps have this current driver ( or something similar ) fitted inside the lamp. These lamps require a constant voltage supply, they do not need and probably will not work if supplied with a constant current from an "electronic transformer" has been sold as an LED driver. Using an LED driver to force a current through the lamps with internal LED driver may damage the lamps and / or the LED driver usedas its power source.
Indeed.

But none of that would change if the names on the enclosures were changed.

People who had no idea what any of it meant, or why it mattered, would not magically acquire that knowledge if the names on the enclosures were changed. Those who do know would find it trivial to discover what the device actually was.

And you KNOW that - it is impossible for you not to know.

If someone goes into a restaurant, and there on the menu they see Chicken And Artichoke Pie, will they know that there are two types of artichoke?

They might, or they might not. If they do know, and if it matters to them, e.g. if they like one type but not the other then they will ask. If they do know but it doesn't matter to them because they like them both then they might not bother. But if they don't know then describing the dish as either Chicken And Globe Artichoke Pie or Chicken And Jerusalem Artichoke Pie won't be of any help to them - they still won't know.

If they have had one type before, and not known which type, and not liked it, then they won't order the pie no matter what it is called because all they know is "I don't like artichokes".

If they have had one type before, and not known which type, and did like it, then they might order the pie because they know "I like artichokes". And they might then discover the hard way that there are different types and they don't like all of them. But identifying them on the menu would have made no difference.



You are just like Winston - the idea that some things are "incorrectly" named sends you into such a frenzied outrage that you are both prepared to lie in order make out that you are right and the entire world is wrong.

Winston tries to deny that they even exist, and you try to claim that the problems of incompatibility, poor quality RFI suppression, incorrect installation etc are due to the "incorrect" names.

But you are both making claims which you know are false.
 
Not ignorant electrians but electricians easily led by the marketing people who can no longer be trusted to tell the truth ( or the whole truth ) about new technology if to do so would compromise sales.
Ooh look - another way you are like Winston.

You've also found a new way to make yourself look idiotic.

So come on then - please put forward a credible explanation of why sales would be compromised if instead of the little plastic boxes being labelled "electronic transformer" the label said "switch mode power supply", or "constant current driver" etc.
 
Thankyou Bernad. So you would agree the name "electronic transformer" was coined by ignorant manufacturers and propagated by ignorant electricians who don't understand what a transformer is
No matter how much you dislike the term, Winston, it is used, and therefore they do exist. If you want it to be otherwise then you must work with the industry to get them to stop using the term, not tell people here that they don't exist.

That your hatred of this is irrational is clearly evinced by the fact that you do not equally object to electronic cigarette, you do not object to electronic book, you do not object to guinea pig and you yourself use the term "electrical world".
 
Sponsored Links
I would remind people that these things are not incorrectly named.

They transform voltage and are electronic in nature.
 
Go on then - explain how that education can only happen if instead of the little plastic boxes being labelled "electronic transformer" the label said "switch mode power supply", or "constant current driver" etc.
 
I wonder if Winston likes Star-trek or does it anger him?



"BLOODY HELL. THAT'S NOT A TRANSPORTER."
 
explain how that education can only happen if instead of the little plastic boxes being labelled "electronic transformer" the label said "switch mode power supply", or "constant current driver" etc.

These devices can cause interference to nearby electronic equipment.

These are American sources where teh problem of Switch Mode Supplies is more widely known in the trade.


https://apps.fcc.gov/oetcf/kdb/forms/FTSSearchResultPage.cfm?id=20450&switch=P

Question: Please provide information regarding incidental and unintentional radiators.

Answer:
Any device that intentionally uses, but does not intentionally radiate RF energy, is classified by the FCC as an Unintentional Radiator and it is subject to technical and administrative requirements in Section15, Subpart B.

A device that produces RF energy only as a by-product of its operation (e.g., a motor) is classified as an Incidental Radiator and is subject to the general requirements in Sections 15.5 & 15.13.

A device that incorporates a switching power supply is clearly a digital device since it intentionally uses a switching regulator operating over 9 KHz to convert electrical power efficiently and is considered a sub-class of Unintentional Radiators.

A device that incorporates a Linear Amplifier may be an Incidental Radiator, provided there are no RF generating components in the device.

Also go to https://www.fcc.gov/oet/ea/rfdevice

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Electromagnetic Compatibility Considerations
for Switching Power Supplies
Switching power supplies generate Electromagnetic Interference (EMI) by
virtue of their inherent design characteristics. Internal switching power supply
circuits that generate undesirable emissions that are rich in harmonics can cause
electrical interference both internally to the circuit in which the power supply is
installed and to other electronic equipment in the vicinity of the emission source.
 
These devices can cause interference to nearby electronic equipment.
Indeed.

Please explain why that potential problem would be in any way different if the device was labelled "switch mode power supply" instead of "electronic transformer". If you cannot do that, then please stop claiming that there are problems because of the name. Because if you cannot do that then it follows that you know your claim is false, and then it follows that you are lying.


These are American sources where teh problem of Switch Mode Supplies is more widely known in the trade.
I'm sure they are.

Please explain why anybody who was legitimately entitled to present himself as a professional, charging money for his services, ought not to know that an electronic transformer is a switch mode power supply.
If you cannot do that, then please stop claiming that there are problems because of the name. Because if you cannot do that then it follows that you know your claim is false, and then it follows that you are lying.


https://apps.fcc.gov/oetcf/kdb/forms/FTSSearchResultPage.cfm?id=20450&switch=P

Question: Please provide information regarding incidental and unintentional radiators.
.
.
.
Jolly good.

Now please explain why this information regarding incidental and unintentional radiators only applies to switch mode power supplies if the label on the outside of the enclosure says "switch mode power supply".
If you cannot do that, then please stop claiming that there are problems because of the name. Because if you cannot do that then it follows that you know your claim is false, and then it follows that you are lying.



Also go to https://www.fcc.gov/oet/ea/rfdevice

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Electromagnetic Compatibility Considerations
for Switching Power Supplies.
.
.
.
Jolly good.

Now please explain how that would mean something to the average DIYer, and that if only the little plastic bricks said "switch mode power supply" and not "electronic transformer" they would know and understand what was inside the little plastic brick and would not get caught out by these problems. If you cannot do that, then please stop claiming that there are problems because of the name. Because if you cannot do that then it follows that you know your claim is false, and then it follows that you are lying.
 
I would remind people that these things are not incorrectly named.

They transform voltage and are electronic in nature.

You are giving false information. These things are NOT transformers. Transformers are wire wound devices that work by magnetic induction.
They usually transform voltage but don't have to. 1:1 isolation transformers don't transform voltage.

These things you refer to are SMPS, no doubt about it.
 
You are giving false information. These things are NOT transformers. Transformers are wire wound devices that work by magnetic induction.
They usually transform voltage but don't have to. 1:1 isolation transformers don't transform voltage.
These things you refer to are SMPS, no doubt about it.
No, it is you who will not accept that anything which transforms anything IS a transformer.

You simply cannot argue with that .


If you want to specify a particular type of transformer then you will have to add one or more descriptors.


Other words for transformer are converter, changer, alterer etc.
 

DIYnot Local

Staff member

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Sponsored Links
Back
Top