Chatting with AIs

[MNW67]

You’re experiencing different advice based on the questions you’ve asked in the session.

I had similar experience when running my FIRE scenarios. You have to check everything, for example it was suggesting some buy and forget ETFs and while the general guidance was good. In one thread it knew the tax implications in another it missed them. It only knows what you tell it in the session. But it learns when corrected.

I don't think so. It's more than that. I started each chat exactly the same by posting the same article and asking for the same help. And the responses were completely different. One was 'this is wonderful writing, I see everything you're trying to do, we just need to make a few little changes'. And the other response was 'this is not a bad start but we need to lose half of it and change the structure totally'. Also, one instance of Claude is really friendly and the other is a little bit aggressive.

 

[Highway Man]

I don't think so. It's more than that. I started each chat exactly the same by posting the same article and asking for the same help. And the responses were completely different. One was 'this is wonderful writing, I see everything you're trying to do, we just need to make a few little changes'. And the other response was 'this is not a bad start but we need to lose half of it and change the structure totally'. Also, one instance of Claude is really friendly and the other is a little bit aggressive.

Wait until they both turn on you, it wont be long.

 

[motorbiking]

I don't think so. It's more than that. I started each chat exactly the same by posting the same article and asking for the same help. And the responses were completely different. One was 'this is wonderful writing, I see everything you're trying to do, we just need to make a few little changes'. And the other response was 'this is not a bad start but we need to lose half of it and change the structure totally'. Also, one instance of Claude is really friendly and the other is a little bit aggressive.

What else had you discussed with it that was different?

 

[motorbiking]

This is what I got back

View attachment 411418

Won’t get building regs on that.

 

[Highway Man]

What else had you discussed with it that was different?

Don't ask.

 

[pete01]

I asked both if pete01 is DIYnot's Number one poster for comedy and factual information and they both agreed, so dunno what you're all on about.

 

[Highway Man]

Won’t get building regs on that.

No door into the conservetory

 

[pete01]

Won’t get building regs on that.

I know the door would have to stay.

 

[MNW67]

What else had you discussed with it that was different?

The main difference was when I have been discussing my article. Because all my other chats have been one offs where we discussed politics, education, foreign affairs and a few other things.