Alloy v Steel Wheels

Joined
1 Feb 2005
Messages
462
Reaction score
8
Location
Tyne and Wear
Country
United Kingdom
Used to hear problems with alloyd, e. G : buckling, leaking.

Are alloys as hood as steel? My gf likes to go "potholing" so are alloys up to scratch?
 
Sponsored Links
Alloys are OK if you keep them clean and drive sensibly. Hard to get a car with steels these days unless you go for the poverty spec.
 
Alloys buckle rather well - especially aftermarket 'fancy' designs......mind you, so do steels but they are much cheaper to replace.
Alloys tend to corrode around the rim which can lead to air loss, similarly around the valve holes. If they are scraped the lacquer fails readily and its not really a DIY job to make good.
John :)
 
so are alloys up to scratch?
They are certainly very easy to scratch, and then they look like shyte.

Only ever had one car with alloys - they leaked air like a sieve and one day while parking lightly clipped the kerb and inexplicably knocked the tyre off the rim.
Never again.
 
Sponsored Links
alloys buckle if they hit things. This leads to lack of balance and air loss, which may be very slow, or catastrophic. The wider they are, the more easily, because the inner edge of the "barrel" is further away from the spokes which are on the outer edge. If it's an expensive wheel it may be worth straightening.

It seems to me that the aftermarket wheels sold to boy racers on price have less metal in them than the ones supplied by car manufacturers. You may notice the spokes are thinner and/or further apart and less of them. I don't think I've ever had a steel wheel go wrong, but alloys, yes.

You can get a set from scrappers cheaply enough, easily matched if they are manufacturer's originals, but it would be sensible to have them inspected and perhaps refurbed by an alloy wheel specialist.

Split rims (tiny bolts hold them together) need to be dismantled and rebuilt with skill, care and new seals. A bodge job may not be apparent but could be disastrous.

The wheel nuts used with steel wheels do not fit alloy wheels correctly and may crack them, so you need a new set.

I prefer a full-size spare. but very big alloys may not fit in the well in the boot.
 
I think steel wheels are available, they have become more popular with the rise of winter tyre sales.

Mind you, both alloy and steel rims can be damaged by potholes.Low profile tyres are more at risk of rim damage.
 
I've never had any problems with alloys in 20 years. I wouldn't want steels with tacky plastic wheel covers. I might not want diamond cut alloys as they are a bit more easily damaged and harder to repair.
 
They probably would if the wheels were a different diameter and width. Insurance quotes these days are primarily for standard vehicles , the call handler wouldn't have the knowledge / authority to deal with a modified vehicle
 
I may be lucky as well, in over 20 years of owning multiple cars, all with GOOD QUALITY alloys I've never suffered a leaking bead or buckled rim.

If you bolt cheap sh1te Chinese knockoffs on your milage may vary.

Plus if you've hit a kerb hard enough to push the tyre off the rim I'm surprised the wheel's not scrap at that point, like complaining of build quality if you drive your car head on into a tree and it breaks...
 
I had to replace the alloys on my merc because they corroded so badly that the tyres wouldn't hold air. It was due to a polished finish and poor lacquer apparently. But IMO Mercedes are sh@te for paint finish.

Even my motorhome had alloys - I think it must be 25+ years since I've had a car with steel wheels
 
There seems to be a problem with the lacquer not adhering to diamond cut alloys, I guess the surface is too smooth.
 
Sponsored Links
Back
Top