Ginger men who now identifies as a woman.

[pete01]

 

[King Billy]

And the nearest you can get to a discussion is childish ad hominem arguments, strawman arguments and meaningless slogans.

A perfect example of the lack of any meaningful argument
.| | | |
VVVV

And the nearest you can get to a discussion is childish ad hominem arguments, strawman arguments and meaningless slogans.

You disappoint me, JohnD. You're reduced to such meaningless posts because a TERF's motivation is hatred and irrational fear for people they don't believe exist.
It's an irrational denial of people's existence which is based on biological nonsense, medical scientific illiteracy and legal confusion.

 

[King Billy]

Isn't there a thread somewhere that you have some understanding of, that you could go and troll there?
Oh, you're already trolling there as well:-

You cant really dispute what I said as I said "FACT" in capital letters....

Wise up(TM)

Yeah maybe, you did say something funny the once, when it comes back to me I'll mention it.

 

[pete01]

Isn't there a thread somewhere that you have some understanding of, that you could go and troll there?
Oh, you're already trolling there as well:-

Why do you care what I do?....

 

[King Billy]

Why do you care what I do?....

View attachment 413568

When you're posting in some of the threads that have become banal through your irrelevant, pointless contributions and trolling, I don't care.
But I do care when you insist on reducing all the threads with your irrelevant nonsense, pointless contributions and trolling.

If you have nothing to say, you're not obliged to say anything.

 

[pete01]

When you're posting in some of the threads that have become banal through your irrelevant, pointless contributions and trolling, I don't care.
But I do care when you insist on reducing all the threads with your irrelevant nonsense, pointless contributions and trolling.

If you have nothing to say, you're not obliged to say anything.

Did I say anything to you?

 

[pete01]

 

[King Billy]

an adult who lives and identifies as female though they may have been considered to have a different sex at birth

Language is alive, it evolves.

An endangered language or moribund language is a language that is at risk of disappearing as its speakers die out or shift to speaking other languages

or the speakers are left behind in their out-dated, irrational or indoctrinated beliefs, like Piers Morgan, J K Rowling and JohnD

Piers Morgan, like J K Rowling and JohnD, is insisting his concept of the meaning of "woman" is the correct meaning.
He is refusing, through his personal ideology, to accept that there are more than one concept of the meaning of woman. That indicates a closed mind.

 

[Odds]

Language is alive, it evolves.

or the speakers are left behind in their out-dated, irrational or indoctrinated beliefs, like Piers Morgan, J K Rowling and JohnD

Piers Morgan, like J K Rowling and JohnD, is insisting his concept of the meaning of "woman" is the correct meaning.
He is refusing, through his personal ideology, to accept that there are more than one concept of the meaning of woman. That indicates a closed mind.

An interesting angle on the subject - can a person born with male chromosomes ( but whose body develops with female physical characteristics due to hormonal issues) ever be perceived as a woman?

 

[King Billy]

An interesting angle on the subject - can a person born with male chromosomes ( but whose body develops with female physical characteristics due to hormonal issues) ever be perceived as a woman?

Yes, a person with male chromosomes (XY) whose body develops with female physical characteristics due to hormonal issues (such as intersex variations or Differences in Sex Development) can be, and often is, perceived and raised as a woman

Woman is defined as a gender, as well as a biological sex, in modern day dictionaries such as the Cambridge Dictionary, referred to in previous post.

In the USA, the definition of "woman" is a subject of intense debate, involving a distinction between biological sex and gender identity. While historically and in some recent legal contexts "woman" refers to biological sex, many social, medical, and legal frameworks now recognize "woman" as a gender identity that can include transgender women.

The Supreme Court judgement determined the legal meaning of the word "woman" only as far as the Equality Act 2010 was concerned.

In For Women Scotland Ltd v The Scottish Ministers the Supreme Court unanimously decided that the definition of the terms “man” “woman” and “sex” in the Equality Act 2010 (EA 2010) refer to a persons biological sex. ...
The Supreme Court stressed in its judgement that it is not the role of the court to adjudicate on the arguments in the public domain on the meaning of gender or sex, nor to define the meaning of the word “woman” other than when it is used in the provisions of the EA 2010.

 

[Odds]

Woman is defined as a gender, as well as a biological sex, in modern day dictionaries such as the Cambridge Dictionary, referred to in previous post.

Nobody - or at least, hardly anyone - carries a dictionary along to discern the finer points of society conventions. People tend to say what they see and without a clear distinction, misunderstandings will accumulate as such arrangements are considered for a minority of our population.

The Supreme Court judgement determined the legal meaning of the word "woman" only as far as the Equality Act 2010 was concerned.

Would you prefer an amendment that goes further to be considered?

 

[JohnD]

Woman is defined as a gender, as well as a biological sex

In reality, however, a "woman" is an adult human female.

Not a man who has uttered the magic words "I am a woman."

You can carry on flogging your Findus meat pie, but it will never grow hooves and carry you to victory.

 

[JohnD]

The Supreme Court judgement determined the legal meaning of the word "woman" only as far as the Equality Act 2010 was concerned.

The Supreme Court knows what a woman is, as do we all, and has said so on the only occasion it was asked.

Do you fantasise that it would stop knowing, if it was asked again?

Feel free to try,

 

[King Billy]

In reality, however, a "woman" is an adult human female.

Not a man who has uttered the magic words "I am a woman."

You can carry on flogging your Findus meat pie, but it will never grow hooves and carry you to victory.

You will carry on with your meaningless slogans, ad hominem attacks and strawman arguments, but your TERF activism based on medical scientific illiteracy, biological nonsense and legal confusion will always remain irrational.

 

[JohnD]

You will carry on with your meaningless slogans

There is nothing meaningless about saying that a woman is an adult human female.

What's your definition?