RCDs and Power Cuts

Joined
2 Jan 2014
Messages
49
Reaction score
1
Location
Yorkshire
Country
United Kingdom
Hi people! Can anyone tell me whether it's indicative of a problem if one of my RCDs trips when the power comes back on after a power cut?
I had a brief power cut a week or so ago, as did the whole neighbourhood given the number of alarms going off, but whilst most of the alarms stopped when it came back on I didn't immediately notice it had come back on for me since the RCD covering my downstairs sockets had tripped and I had no ceiling light on.
The RCD in question is one of 2 on a dual-RCD board and covers downstairs and kitchen ring finals, boiler, and basement lights. It is a bit annoying that the lights in the basement where the CU is are on the same RCD as said ring finals!
No white goods other than the fridge/freezer were running at the time of the power cut. Could it just be one of those things? Sorry for the long message.
 
Sponsored Links
... Could it just be one of those things?
Very probably - such things have been known to happen (including to me!).

If I were you, I would just wait to see if anything similar (in fact, any other 'unexpected' RCD trips) occurs again, and delay any 'worrying' unless/until that happens. If you wanted to be more 'pro-active' than that, I suppose you could avoid having to wait for the next power cut by simulating one - by operating the Main Switch in your CU!

Kind Regards, John
 
Its not unkown.

Ours (a Wylex 63A 30mA) often trips when the power returns. I think its due to a large surge current when all those switch mode power supplies start to refill their reservoir caps - it will often know out the 32A MCB on the ring final to. If I reset quickly then they both hold & all is well.
 
Sponsored Links
My old house it was common for RCD to trip with power cut or even resetting the other RCD. When fitted the RCBO was not really an option with a single modular width, the only way was for one RCD covering many circuits.

Today we should measure the back ground leakage, but we rarely do, the recommended 9 mA maximum back ground leakage is all well and good in theory, in practice I don't have a meter to measure it. And the instructions given to electricians when going to collage seem flawed, we are told to test the RCD with no load at ½ its rating so with a 30 mA test at 15 mA but with circuits disconnected, if we tested with circuits connected it would be far better, we would then know the RCD would not trip with an extra 15 mA and also it is not being frozen by any DC when tested it does trip at 30 mA, however traditionally we test with all circuits off.

AC current will always leak to a small extent, capacitive and inductive linking means there is always a little, years ago when we used 100 mA this was not enough to worry about, however it is with 30 mA, although the regulations have said the supply should be split into circuits to "reduce the possibility of unwanted tripping of RCDs due to excessive protective conductor currents produced by equipment in normal operation" electricians have decided not to think of the RCD as forming a circuit, defined as "An assembly of electrical equipment supplied from the same origin and protected against overcurrent by the same protective device(s)." it clearly is an overcurrent, but to earth rather than to power a device, and we have as a trade hidden behind the definition.

It is all down to price, I have just looked on internet and a 10 way consumer unit with 2 RCD's advertised at £50, but a 10 way consumer unit with all RCBO and SPD without the RCBO's is £60 populated £231.60 with each RCBO costing £17.16, and the £50 one is on offer, likely because electricians are now realising they should not really be fitting a 10 way with just two RCD's and as you move to smaller units the RCBO works out cheaper anyway.

I did not measure the leakage with my own house, little point, fitting all RCBO so if over 9 mA not much I could do about it without a rewire, but on that 10 way example the home could leak 10 x 30 mA so 300 mA collectivity before it trips, but on a twin RCD only 2 x 30 mA so 60 mA, we know from past experience the 100 mA trips rarely had a nuisance trip, they only tended to trip with a true fault, and the RCBO with less wiring on each unit also rarely has a nuisance trip, but a 30 mA with multi-circuits it does vary from home to home, some people seem to get away with them, but others it is common for them to trip.

Personally last house fitted around 1992, and I would get a bout of tripping, maybe every week for 6 weeks, then 2 years before next trip, I would test the RCD with a RCD tester not just the button, no fault found, and test the circuits with an insulation tester again no fault found, just before moving lost a pair of freezers full of food, so with this house I fitted all RCBO's. The extra £200 for all RCBO's is less than what I lost when freezers defrosted.

But be it a single or multi RCD (RCBO is an MCB and RCD combined) or fitting a surge protection device, it does not cause a danger to personal, only to loss of equipment or goods, so the electrician can't force the home owner to fit RCBO's or SPD it is the owners call as to if they want them or not. However as electricians we maybe don't explain before doing the work what it means when only two RCD's fitted or no SPD are fitted.
 

DIYnot Local

Staff member

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Back
Top