CH inhibitor test strips - worth it ?

Joined
27 Jul 2006
Messages
562
Reaction score
10
Country
United Kingdom
Hi all,

I was just wondering what everyone's thoughts are on the inhibitor test strips to test strength
You may recall i did a clean of my system which took ages to flush, mainly due to me overdosing with cleaner but i eventually did it with guidance from this forum, but i would now like to just take a sample and test

Are they any good as they seem pretty expensive, particularly for a DIYer ?
Also, are they generic or do you need to use the Adey test strips if you've used the Adey inhibitor ?

I'm due to have my boiler serviced so will ask my engineer too but i'm interested all the same

TIA
 
Try this free test. Drain a drop of your central heating fluid into a container. In another container, put the same amount of tap water. Drop a bright steel nail into both containers. After a couple of days, have a look at them. You’ll soon know whether you have enough corrosion inhibitor in the system.

Here’s mine after about 4 days. Tap water on the left. Mind you, the system water on the right may be due for a top up. I put my inhibitor in 9 years ago when the new boiler was installed and I’ve changed a few rads and done the odd top up since then - it’s starting to look a bit discoloured and it’s normally gin clear.

IMG_5096.jpeg
 
Last edited:
honestly mate for a diyer they're a waste of money, you're looking at £25 for strips when a fresh bottle of fernox f1 or sentinel x100 is half that. if you've flushed it properly just tip a full bottle straight in for peace of mind, you can't really overdose modern inhibitor anyway. most gas engineers carry dropper test kits on the van and check it on the annual boiler service as standard.
 
cheers @Mottie @wazzheed

I'll see if my engineer carries them and ask if he can do a test during the service

Interesting about not being able to overdose the system
When i was preparing to add the inhibitor, i engaged the Adey tech support team and asked about double dosing and they specifically said not to, although didn't give a reason
 
cheers @Mottie @wazzheed

I'll see if my engineer carries them and ask if he can do a test during the service

Interesting about not being able to overdose the system
When i was preparing to add the inhibitor, i engaged the Adey tech support team and asked about double dosing and they specifically said not to, although didn't give a reason
no worries mate, adey probably just cover their backs so people don't turn their system water into pure syrup haha. standard 500ml bottle is formulated for around a 100 litre system (roughly 10 rads), so even in a smaller house one whole bottle is sound. definitely worth getting your bloke to test it when he services the boiler though, saves you buying a full kit.
 
I have a over 50 year old open vent system (combined cold feed&Vent but with the vent carrying on up and over the F&E cistern), some rads are over 40 years old and to say the system has adequate inhibitor would be a vey large stretch of my imagination, I throw the odd drop in after draining down the occasional rad to replace a TRV. I often wonder is it is because my 20 year old oil fired boiler's HEX is just a steel box, the only dissimilar metals are probably the brass fittings in the system whereas a lot of gas boilers have aluminium HEXs, maybe this invites more corrosion. To get corrosion there must be oxygen in the water, I just wonder does a OV system get rid of this better than a sealed system, the water in my system is almost crystal clear, I have a 1/2 ins isolation valve to the feed to the F&E ballcock that I keep closed but open it maybe every 3 months to check for any usage/evaporation as I cannot see into the F&E cistern which is perched up very high just below the roof. I have never heard as much as a drop of makeup water entering this cistern. One other thing which may have a influence is that the mains water here seems to be of very high quality with absolutely no limescale or the like, I know this because I still have a exactly 54 year old cylinder immersion that I installed a few days after moving into this (then new) house in October 1972, I self installed a solar thermal system ~ 20 years ago with a new twin coil HW cylinder and removed the immersion, then ~ 34 years old and its heating elements had no scaling whatsoever, so I just re used it. I also replaced a 18 year old 9kW electric shower about 3 years ago and removed the heating elements (No, I didn't reuse them!), to have a look at them, these also had no scaling whatsoever.

Is there any merit in filling a (especially new) system with demineralised water if the water quality isn't known, maybe not, because one would require a pump to top up the system with demin water later on to avoid using mains top up.

I will carry out @Mottie s shiny nail test if I can find one
 
Last edited:
no worries mate, adey probably just cover their backs so people don't turn their system water into pure syrup haha. standard 500ml bottle is formulated for around a 100 litre system (roughly 10 rads), so even in a smaller house one whole bottle is sound. definitely worth getting your bloke to test it when he services the boiler though, saves you buying a full kit.syrup ….. yes I guess what you are saying about Adey covering themselves
The dosage that you refer to is interesting

From the details on the back of the MC1+ inhibitor bottle, it says that the dosage should be 0.4% of the total volume of the system so for the calculations that I did of my radiators of which I have only eight although one of them is pretty huge and using details from the manufacturers regarding their volume figures for he tried if I recall correctly mine only required just over 200 mL
no worries mate, adey probably just cover their backs so people don't turn their system water into pure syrup haha. standard 500ml bottle is formulated for around a 100 litre system (roughly 10 rads), so even in a smaller house one whole bottle is sound. definitely worth getting your bloke to test it when he services the boiler though, saves you buying a full kit.

@wazzheed …. Syrup
Yes, I get what you are saying about Adey covering themselves

The dosage you mentioned is interesting
I used MC1+ inhibitor and it says that the dosage is 0.4% of total volume of system

I got The volume details for each of my radiators from the manufacturers and then estimated the pipework length also and from looking at my notes, for eight radiators of which one of them is large, I think the radiators was only just over 30 L unless I have got my mathematics completely wrong

This is partly the reason why I want to do a strength test

Here is a photo of the back of the bottle
 

Attachments

  • IMG_4154.jpeg
    IMG_4154.jpeg
    986.7 KB · Views: 0

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Back
Top