Earth problem from boiler tripping RCD

Joined
24 Mar 2023
Messages
6
Reaction score
2
Country
United Kingdom
Hi everyone,
I am after some advice. We had a new consumer unit fitted with an RCD and when we switch the boiler/heating on it trips the
RCD.
The boiler is wired to the consumer unit via the ring main with a 32a fuse.

We have an old boiler (ideal Mexico floor standing boiler with a separate hot water tank.)
We have checked the fused spur and it is working correctly. (When in the off position sockets work fine)

The electrician checked this.

We have found a bad earth between the controller unit (Honeywell st6400c) and the boiler (Honeywell type v 460 E).
The blue wire!

Has anyone had this problem?
The electrician stopped at this point.

Would changing the Honeywell Type 4600e be the next step or can any more fault finding be done?
(Obviously for a plumber/boiler engineer)

Many thanks.
 
Sponsored Links
A neutral (Blue or Black in old money) connected to earth (Green/Yellow- old or new) or vice versa would explain an RCD tripping. Check there are no connections between N and E anywhere in the heating system.

Once wired an oven and the clock worked fine, as soon as heat was required it tripped the RCD. I had N and E transposed and the clock current wasn't enough to trip the RCD - load current would.
 
Sponsored Links
Hi, thank you for your reply.... update. Had a boiler breakdown engineer who thinks it may be the wiring center upstairs next to the tank. He wasn’t 100% but recommended changing it.
 
it wont be the wiring centre, it is simply terminal strip in a box, it cant go faulty, post pics of the "Blue wire " at both ends
 
  • Thanks
Reactions: CBW
It is one of the blue wires on the left. The one with the 3 going into the same terminal.
One blue goes from the fuse spur, the other to the wiring center and the other to the boiler below. (This is the one that ‘goes to earth’ when tested with a multimeter on continuity.
 

Attachments

  • CACCD24B-D714-4BB1-995F-39C5F53F11C2.jpeg
    CACCD24B-D714-4BB1-995F-39C5F53F11C2.jpeg
    200.4 KB · Views: 82
  • 4FBEF6A0-9D80-4153-81F6-4860E060F5F4.jpeg
    4FBEF6A0-9D80-4153-81F6-4860E060F5F4.jpeg
    212.2 KB · Views: 72
Show us a picture of what you mean by "wiring center". More pictures are better than fewer. Be careful using terms like "below" - it doesn't matter to us what the orientation of things in your house is/where your boiler components area screwed to the wall relative to each other, but when you write a post, words and pictures are above/below each other, which can make for confusing reading (neither of the pictures "below" your words appear to be a boiler, so "boiler below" doesn't make sense)
 
when you turn the fused spur on does it trip straight away or not
and does it then trip when you select heating or hot water
 
I thought N to E should read 0 ohms and only read "infinity" if the consumer is isolated from the supply with say a DP isolator.
 
Thank you everyone for your feedback. It will try to be less confusing with my explanations.

When you turn on the fused spur it trips the rcd (straight away)

We found that 1 of the 3 blue wires in the connector on the left was measuring to earth (using continuity). The wire was connecting Honeywell ST6400c to the boiler Honeywell Type v 4600e.
I have drawn a diagram and have taken more photos
 

Attachments

  • 786AD96A-7057-47D9-9F00-3E3CA12ACCA1.jpeg
    786AD96A-7057-47D9-9F00-3E3CA12ACCA1.jpeg
    271 KB · Views: 84
  • 4E2496E8-3F17-4181-A8C4-3BA6F4C31047.jpeg
    4E2496E8-3F17-4181-A8C4-3BA6F4C31047.jpeg
    310.4 KB · Views: 75
  • 27BC8732-9FE3-46AD-B8A5-C1C057D8E737.jpeg
    27BC8732-9FE3-46AD-B8A5-C1C057D8E737.jpeg
    230.6 KB · Views: 73
  • 99D6DBD8-5924-45A3-B405-C2BDD8B34045.jpeg
    99D6DBD8-5924-45A3-B405-C2BDD8B34045.jpeg
    192.4 KB · Views: 70
  • C6A2BE78-CC79-4FA5-BD53-139B8604EF15.jpeg
    C6A2BE78-CC79-4FA5-BD53-139B8604EF15.jpeg
    212.9 KB · Views: 60
  • 9D39BFB7-CDCC-43E5-A4BC-8C8ED66C0DE1.jpeg
    9D39BFB7-CDCC-43E5-A4BC-8C8ED66C0DE1.jpeg
    257.4 KB · Views: 76
  • DE60A669-2D37-47C8-A350-977487F86763.jpeg
    DE60A669-2D37-47C8-A350-977487F86763.jpeg
    184.4 KB · Views: 58
  • 0CEB8C11-AA04-4266-BAFF-F1135402F2C8.jpeg
    0CEB8C11-AA04-4266-BAFF-F1135402F2C8.jpeg
    254.7 KB · Views: 78
Tripping straight away First thing you should be checking is that no water has got into the motorised valves possibly dripping from pump above them .
 
The blue (appears to be neutral) wire from programmer seems to be connected to the earth connection at the Honeywell wiring center? Could also be a switch live causing a short circuit.
 
Thanks, will check this out. But visually it looks dry but will investigate further
 
Your wiring is wrong but shouldnt cause the fault you have, the permanent L,N&E from the fused spur should go to the bottom right hand terminal on the wiring centre, yours goes to the programmer back plate this is wrong the wiring centre needs a permanent live, yours is running on switched lives
 
  • Thanks
Reactions: CBW

DIYnot Local

Staff member

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Sponsored Links
Back
Top