Porch roof still leaking after hip and ridge tiles reset by roofer

Joined
8 Oct 2020
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
Country
United Kingdom
Hi all. This is my first post so please be kind.

In May this year our porch was showing a leak on the plasterboard ceiling where the porch wall meets the house. The porch is 12 years old, three sided into the corner of our L shaped bungalow, with a pitched, pintiled roof and two lead valleys.
The lead valleys had new mortar fillets between lead and tiles fitted about 5 years ago and look in good condition
In the roof I could see damp under the membrane on the hip rafter that sits above the house wall and this ran down into the area above the leak stain on the ceiling. The hip tiles mortar joints all looked a bit flaky so I had a local roofer that we’ve used before reset all the porch hip and ridge tiles.

From May until September we’ve had very little rain here in Suffolk and all seemed well with no sign of the leak.

After the heavy rain we’ve had these past few weeks the leak stain reappeared on the porch ceiling and started spreading. I looked up in the loft again and could see what appeared to be three leak sites
One appears to be from the reset hip tiles again and I can see wet running down the hip rafter into the leak stain area
Two appear to be from the reset ridge tiles as the membrane has damp patches running down from ridge to the valley board. Looks like the water is then caught in the valley mortar fillet, soaks through the membrane and runs down the valley board to the area above the ceiling leak stain.

The porch roof tiles and mortar joints on the ridge / hip tiles look perfect on the outside so I’m struggling to decide what to do next. I had thought of waiting for a dry spell and then blasting the whole roof with Thompson’s Water seal but Id rather get a proper job done.

Any suggestions gratefully received

Many thanks
John
 

Attachments

  • 04B26DFC-A533-46D7-A9C1-B29B91879973.jpeg
    04B26DFC-A533-46D7-A9C1-B29B91879973.jpeg
    237.3 KB · Views: 300
  • A494EF25-D074-4C6B-98C0-9806CAB63E9E.jpeg
    A494EF25-D074-4C6B-98C0-9806CAB63E9E.jpeg
    204.6 KB · Views: 324
  • 09242879-4971-4C05-82CF-870EE9C0973F.jpeg
    09242879-4971-4C05-82CF-870EE9C0973F.jpeg
    303.1 KB · Views: 300
  • 8EB55C0E-6ED9-444A-BB85-2D60AAB90513.jpeg
    8EB55C0E-6ED9-444A-BB85-2D60AAB90513.jpeg
    321.9 KB · Views: 300
  • A3592AF3-FB19-487E-B29E-E8AEBEAEE834.jpeg
    A3592AF3-FB19-487E-B29E-E8AEBEAEE834.jpeg
    346.5 KB · Views: 324
Sponsored Links
Does the lead valley have a welt/tilt fillet?
Out of curiosity what is the pitch of the roof?
 
Hi and thanks for the quick reply.

There is no welt on the lead valley

The roof pitch on the leaking side is 35 degrees

John
 
Hi Barthy,
The weather here is not so good for removing the porch valley tiles this next week
Just wondering if I could remove the lead valley mortar fillets and use a mastic sealer to make a temporary welt down each side of the lead to tide me over the winter?
Thanks
 
Sponsored Links
Weather in Portsmouth isn't too great either pal.
I wouldn't advise it to be honest.
Do you know the valley width I personally would recommend 450mm minimum with a clear 125mm channel in the centre.
It isn't too difficult to strip and number tiles, make good or install sufficient lead valley (with small tilt/welt) fix fibre cement strips in line with valley tiles with flexible mastic and mortar the valley as before.
Or alternatively opt for the fibreglass route.
 
a couple of pictures showing the roof as a whole would be useful.

Mortar work looks a bit amateurish maybe close up of that too.
 
Thanks Barthy,

The valley lead is 450mm and channel is about 200mm wide.
Are the fibre cement strips meant as an additional barrier ?

Cheers
John
 
Hi datarebal,
Thanks for the reply.

mortar was replaced 5 years ago by a local roofer. He didn’t spot the missing lead welt/tilt
I’ve added some extra pics showing the complete porch, valley mortar, damp area, wet valley boards, wet membrane.

Cheers
John
 

Attachments

  • 231B7986-1562-4CC5-BF72-1F5A0962A6CA.jpeg
    231B7986-1562-4CC5-BF72-1F5A0962A6CA.jpeg
    240.9 KB · Views: 277
  • E743FC31-324C-4F67-963A-4E1AD3F9E01E.jpeg
    E743FC31-324C-4F67-963A-4E1AD3F9E01E.jpeg
    204.6 KB · Views: 258
  • 36B56CD4-5A23-4550-A81A-9383B5928EC4.jpeg
    36B56CD4-5A23-4550-A81A-9383B5928EC4.jpeg
    466.4 KB · Views: 292
  • 52581E45-5480-4D92-80EF-185DBAA3933A.jpeg
    52581E45-5480-4D92-80EF-185DBAA3933A.jpeg
    355.5 KB · Views: 253
  • 386341A1-104E-4999-8221-FC3426A9115A.jpeg
    386341A1-104E-4999-8221-FC3426A9115A.jpeg
    321.6 KB · Views: 261
  • 4261EED1-7251-4E62-9A0A-87134D8C377E.jpeg
    4261EED1-7251-4E62-9A0A-87134D8C377E.jpeg
    211.6 KB · Views: 272
  • 34F1F69C-F328-4348-949B-4982E98945D3.jpeg
    34F1F69C-F328-4348-949B-4982E98945D3.jpeg
    303.1 KB · Views: 289
  • 46711B56-4B10-4D24-9F49-340E5BC2CAD2.jpeg
    46711B56-4B10-4D24-9F49-340E5BC2CAD2.jpeg
    321.9 KB · Views: 306
  • F264EA12-3010-48D8-98C3-AB3094278466.png
    F264EA12-3010-48D8-98C3-AB3094278466.png
    2.4 MB · Views: 278
  • 3DBD578E-D508-4F33-AD5D-0BE5284B11DB.jpeg
    3DBD578E-D508-4F33-AD5D-0BE5284B11DB.jpeg
    230.5 KB · Views: 273
Water seal will not solve anything.
Re bedding the hips the other roofer may not have exposed the lead valley detailing.
So would not know if there is turn ups.. Welts or anything else.
Inside the loft there are a few nails poking through not good.
You will need to strip out some tiles each side of the valley. There maybe a few damaged ones not obvious to you
Once you ave exposed that area if its not damaged tiles , likely it could be excess mortar spread out over the edge of the lead. seeing as the valley mortar has cracked away from the tile cut edge. Water can easily track back under and onto the underlay which is damaged anyway.. welt or not
 
Last edited:
Thanks datarebal, much appreciated.

Inside the roof I can see and feel the valley fillet mortar pushing against the membrane and bulging it over the valley board. The membrane is soaking wet just above the top of the valley board in a few places. This is running down the valley board into the corner

in the picture where the hip rafter and valley board meet at the corner you can see water running down the left side short rafter that comes down from the hip rafter. Could this be coming from the hip ridge tiles or is it still likely to be water washing over the mortar the lead and soaking across?

Many thanks
John
 
if you can feel the mortar then its wrong and needs stripping out. the tiles should not be bedded directly on the lead anyway.
As for the hip leak the pictures do not help a lot, could be damaged tiles as i said before. a few need to come out to see.
 
Thanks datarebal and Barthy......wish you guys were up here in Beccles!

The roofer who replaced the valley mortar 5 years ago is a nice guy. He’s done a few jobs for us and always tries his best to come out and help at short notice. He’s here tomorrow to take out the valley mortar and we can decide what to do from there

Barthy, I understand the cement fibre strips now...thanks

Guys......How should the roofer be re-mortaring the valley fillets to leave a gap to the membrane........or is that just skill?

Many thanks guys
John
 

DIYnot Local

Staff member

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Sponsored Links
Back
Top