Sorry, but this is important.

[pete01]

and to add, they wouldnt even have had those thoughts unless some crank had put it there.

Exactly what I've been saying, dont put it into their heads.

 

[morqthana]

OMG, you dont half twist things....

No, I go on the basis of what you actually write.

you know I meant I wouldnt want my child to be told they can change sex if they wanted to,

You didn't say you'd punch someone who told your child they could change sex if they wanted to (not something which is true anyway), you said you'd punch them if they told your child that not everybody falls into the binary categories of only either male or female.

 

[pete01]

Pete01 did not say "a total stranger", he said "anyone".

OMG you're losing face so pick on that....LOL

 

[Highway Man]

Pete01 did not say "a total stranger", he said "anyone".

nd that has no causal relationship to the fact that sex isn't binary, except in the frothing imaginations of transphobes.

Yours are the rantings of a lunatic,, Think on...

 

[pete01]

Yours are the rantings of a lunatic,, Think on...

He's lost the plot

 

[Highway Man]

He's lost the plot

I know

 

[fixitflav]

What should the teacher do if a child says he has two mummies and no daddy?

Teach the child the three Rs and mind his own business

 

[pete01]

No, I go on the basis of what you actually write.




You didn't say you'd punch someone who told your child they could change sex if they wanted to (not something which is true anyway), you said you'd punch them if they told your child that not everybody falls into the binary categories of only either male or female.

Im a lover not a fighter...I also wrote that.

 

[morqthana]

OMG you're losing face so pick on that....LOL

I'm not picking on anything. I'm quoting what you actually wrote. We're not allowed to falsify quotes to make it look as if people wrote something they didn't.

 

[pete01]

I'm not picking on anything. I'm quoting what you actually wrote. We're not allowed to falsify quotes to make it look as if people wrote something they didn't.

Ok

 

[Highway Man]

No, I go on the basis of what you actually write.




You didn't say you'd punch someone who told your child they could change sex if they wanted to (not something which is true anyway), you said you'd punch them if they told your child that not everybody falls into the binary categories of only either male or female.

Think on...

 

[Koolpc]

All you've done there is to show that you cannot comprehend the idea of anybody viewing social issues in any way except through the prism of what is in their own direct self-interest.

Well, you seem fixated on men being allowed into women's rest rooms wearing dresses and thinking that it's all ok.....

 

[morqthana]

No he didn't, stop making things up.

Yes he did. I'm not making things up.

That was not the context

OK, let's look at the context. This was the sequence of posts

How can there anything else other than male and female?

Asking for a friend

On average, females tend to have XX chromosomes and males tend to have XY chromosomes.

But those are not the only options, the situation is absolutely not a binary male or female.

In humans, the following sex chromosome variations are naturally occurring:

45, X, also called Turner syndrome
45,X/46, also called XY mosaicism
46, XX/XY
47, XXX, also called Trisomy X
47, XXY, also called Klinefelter syndrome
47, XYY with normal phenotype
48, XXXX
48, XXXY
48, XXYY
49, XXXXY
49, XXXXX
XX Male Syndrome
XX Gonadal Dysgenesis
XY Gonadal Dysgenesis

Have a day off, it's male or female end of ya div

You denying scientific reality will not make it go away.

Its male or female, anyone who told my child otherwise would get a smack in the chops

So the context was not sex changes. It was not transgenderism. It was not about strangers filling childrens heads with ideas that they can choose to change their sex.

It was clearly and unequivocally a factual, scientifically truthful answer to the question Pete asked. And equally clearly and unequivocally Pete said that anyone who told his child those facts would get a smack in the chops.

The problem he has, and you, JohnD, KoolPC, and many others have, is that you will not stop conflating the belief that scientific facts about sex matter, and the belief that any man can become a woman just by saying so.

 

[pete01]

I'll rephrase it then anyone who puts silly ideas into my normal happy loving child's head will get a smack in the chops.

The smack part is said in jest, theu will probablyget a good finger point ...as im a lover not a fighter

 

[morqthana]

Well, you seem fixated on men being allowed into women's rest rooms wearing dresses and thinking that it's all ok.....

That's utterly untrue. You won't find a single thing I've written to justify it. You will find this, though

I don't for one second think that a man should automatically have access to women-only spaces just by saying "I identify as a woman", and I've always said that.

And this:

There are genuine and justified concerns about how to deal with trans people in the context of same-sex spaces such as prisons, hospital wards, domestic violence refuges, and how to ensure fairness in sport, for example,

But of course it doesn't suit you to accept things like that, does it.