Henry Nowak inquest...

noseall · 2 Jul 2026

morqthana said:
I don't. But let's take Dec27 at his word, and accept that he was a bit careless, that's all, and meant, and meant to write, "income tax".

Dec27 - can you explain how you "know" that there are 8 million people in the UK who pay more in income tax than they "take out"?

Will you please reference the official data on which you are relying for that claim?

Considering he thought those paying income tax were the only contributors to the UK coffers, I would not bother. Maths is not his strong point.

morqthana · 2 Jul 2026

Dec27 said:
The initial reply was to noseal, you can tell I quoted his post…..

In another post you quoted noseall.

But in the post of yours which prompted me to ask you in what way and why I'm not welcome, you quoted me. (And yourself).

Look:

noseall · 2 Jul 2026

King Billy said:
I don't know where he gets the figure of 8 milion from:

The same place he gets his UK tax contributors knowledge from - plucked from the air.

morqthana · 2 Jul 2026

King Billy said:
I don't know where he gets the figure of 8 milion from:

He must have got it from somewhere, otherwise he'd just be making things up without caring if they are true or not, and what sort of person would do that?

He must have a source.

noseall · 2 Jul 2026

morqthana said:
He must have got it from somewhere, otherwise he'd just be making things up without caring

I think he's too busy back-peddling to find out.

Dec27 · 2 Jul 2026

morqthana said:
He must have got it from somewhere, otherwise he'd just be making things up without caring if they are true or not, and what sort of person would do that?

He must have a source.

I do yes. But it’s getting daft now.

Whatever I post wheel barrow Boyo won’t accept it.

Google it, if you’re actually bothered. Then you’ll find how much the top 1% income tax payers contribute to the uk.

King Billy · 2 Jul 2026

morqthana said:
He must have got it from somewhere, otherwise he'd just be making things up without caring if they are true or not, and what sort of person would do that?

He must have a source.

It's Honey Mustard sauce that he has.

Let your imagination run wild

morqthana · 2 Jul 2026

Dec27 said:
Oh right… I said @noseal was welcome for the extra we pay to cover his socialist dream/ lifestyle. As he pays tax on 50k “his stated figure” so he’s not in the higher bands.

And I said you’re not welcome. As I imagine you’re in the top 1% of income tax payers.

Got it ? Or do you want to try and drag it out……

OK - let's forget everything that may or may not have been replies from you to noseall, or replies from noseall to you, and what the context of "you're not welcome" was, and just deal with what you posted as a standalone comment.

Dec27 said:
You know there’s 8 million tax payers in the UK who put in more than they take out.

So?

Dec27 · 2 Jul 2026

morqthana said:
OK - let's forget everything that may or may not have been replies from you to noseall, or replies from noseall to you, and what the context of "you're not welcome" was, and just deal with what you posted as a standalone comment.

So?

Did you not read all my reply… don’t you pay loads of tax ?

So there’s no need for you to be welcome, is there ?

King Billy · 2 Jul 2026

noseall said:
I think he's too busy back-peddling to find out.

Dec27 said:
Did you not read all my reply… don’t you pay loads of tax ?

So there’s no need for you to be welcome, is there ?

And side-stepping now. He'll be doing the hokey cokey in a minute.

morqthana · 2 Jul 2026

Dec27 said:
I do yes. But it’s getting daft now.

Whatever I post wheel barrow Boyo won’t accept it.

If you show verifiable facts, they have to be accepted - they can't not be.

So post verifiable facts and you won't have the problem of barrow Boyo not accepting them, will you.

Do you not realise that if you continue to refuse, people might start thinking that you really did make it up, and that you really don't care if what you write is true. And who would want that?

Dec27 said:
Google it, if you’re actually bothered. Then you’ll find how much the top 1% income tax payers contribute to the uk.

We were talking about your claim that 8 million income tax payers in the UK put in more than they take out.

8 million can't be the top 1%

Accredited official statistics
Summary Statistics
there were 33.0 million Income Tax payers in tax year 2021 to 2022, which is projected to increase to 37.4 million in 2024 to 2025

Dec27 · 2 Jul 2026

morqthana said:
If you show verifiable facts, they have to be accepted - they can't not be.

Do you not realise that if you continue to refuse, people might start thinking that you really did make it up, and that you really don't care if what you write is true. And who would want that?

We were talking about your claim that 8 million income tax payers in the UK put in more than they take out.

8 million can't be the top 1%

https://www.gov.uk/government/stati...2-to-tax-year-2024-to-2025/summary-statistics

It’s obvious you either can’t, or won’t absorb what I’m saying.

Let’s just say I made it up then, are we done now ?

Oh and I’m one of the most popular posters. So whatever you and wheel barrow boyo think isn’t worth much lol

King Billy · 2 Jul 2026

Dec27 said:
Let’s just say I made it up then, are we done now ?

Shouldn't this be in the "You couldn't make it up" thread but you did.

morqthana · 2 Jul 2026

Dec27 said:
Did you not read all my reply… don’t you pay loads of tax ?

So there’s no need for you to be welcome, is there ?

That has absolutely nothing to do with why it matters that (if) there are 8 million income tax payers in the UK who put in more than they take out.

There's more than one way I could have phrased my question about that:

Dec27 said:
You know there’s 8 million tax payers in the UK who put in more than they take out.

So?
So what?
Why does that matter?
Why is that a problem?
And your point is?

But one answer will suffice.

morqthana · 2 Jul 2026

Dec27 said:
Let’s just say I made it up then, are we done now ?

Almost.

Dec27 said:
Oh and I’m one of the most popular posters. So whatever you and wheel barrow boyo think isn’t worth much lol

I'm not surprised - there are a lot of people here who see nothing wrong with just making stuff up, and not caring if what they write is true.

Henry Nowak inquest...

Similar threads