Electric Saw

Joined
11 Jan 2004
Messages
46,883
Reaction score
3,987
Country
United Kingdom
Hello

I'm looking for an electric saw, but not a chain saw, for garden work.

Which is the best type and a decent mid-range brand?
 
just make sure you dont get the blade pinched or you will do a good impersonation off a tree shaker

as an aside
ryobi do dozens off 18v tools now just for the garden
 
ryobi seem to be doing a sale specifically suited to your needs-----spooky

Ideal for light to medium gardening.

That's a pretty good price for the chainsaw!

I wonder if the Aldi/middle of Lidl specials are hitting the likes of Ryobi in the pocket?
 
Ideal for light to medium gardening.

That's a pretty good price for the chainsaw!

I wonder if the Aldi/middle of Lidl specials are hitting the likes of Ryobi in the pocket?
you rember ---made me laugh :giggle:
 
Back here looking for a power saw.

I did buy one like the one Deluks recommended.
Brilliant for a hand saw, but I'd like something with some power behind it now

I like the idea of the Ryobi kit. In the same vein, I have a load of DeWalt 18V batteries and a charger and some drill drivers and a reciprocating tool.

So, I could buy a DeWalt saw to add to the collection.

Or another brand, of course.

Robin was correct about chainsaws, I am avoiding them, and jj hit the nail on the head; they are a bit scary.

Plus, there's reviews on Screwfix of the DeWalt one that says it leaks oil all the time, which is not encouraging.

There is the B & D Alligator saw, which seems a lot safer, but I haven't met anyone who has got one.

Any recommendations for chopping branches up to 100 milli?
 
We've had to do a huge amount of garden clearing at our new place and my trusty old Erbauer (corded) recip has done most of the work up to about 150 diameter (at which point the chain saw comes out).

Bosch blades £15 for 5 at Toolsation are great and last a long time and you don't mind cutting roots which don't do a chainsaw any good
 
Back here looking for a power saw.

I did buy one like the one Deluks recommended.
Brilliant for a hand saw, but I'd like something with some power behind it now

I like the idea of the Ryobi kit. In the same vein, I have a load of DeWalt 18V batteries and a charger and some drill drivers and a reciprocating tool.

So, I could buy a DeWalt saw to add to the collection.

Or another brand, of course.

Robin was correct about chainsaws, I am avoiding them, and jj hit the nail on the head; they are a bit scary.

Plus, there's reviews on Screwfix of the DeWalt one that says it leaks oil all the time, which is not encouraging.

There is the B & D Alligator saw, which seems a lot safer, but I haven't met anyone who has got one.

Any recommendations for chopping branches up to 100 milli?
Chainsaws weep oil , that is never owned one that doesn’t .
I use these in a recip ,
 
There is the B & D Alligator saw, which seems a lot safer, but I haven't met anyone who has got one.
We have a large garden that had been left to go rather wild, lots of holly, laurel & yew as well as nice trees that needed work.

A friend suggested that an Alligator saw might be useful and I bought one. That was well over a decade ago, back then the batteries were not Li-ion, so they did not keep their charge if left unused. Also they seemed to run out of juice quite quickly. So I bought a cordless drill set as that included two batteries and it was cheaper than buying the batteries separately!

I used it a lot and it was very effective. The downsides:
- Battery life was poor, that may be better now the batteries are Li-ion.
- The jaws, obviously, don't open very far, so there is a limit on how thick a branch you can cut.
- It does not have a proper oil reservoir, see the last photo here
There is, AFAIUI, a short length of pipe that you fill with oil and this drains onto the chain, but you cannot see how much oil there is in there.

Eventually the batteries died and I could not get any more (clearly they saw there was an issue) and the tool was only available as a corded item. Since then they must have reintroduced it with different batteries. Li-ion batteries can be much better, see below.

By then I had bought a petrol powered chainsaw so this tool being U/S was not an issue for me. With that chainsaw I also bought PPE; kevlar gloves, ear defenders, face mask, etc.


At some stage I bought a reciprocating saw and when using it to cut branches I uses these
The former are 5TPI and the latter 3TPI.


Somewhere, maybe on this site, I read that bow saws come with a peg tooth blade that is not that good for cutting wood and that a better option is a raker tooth blade like this
The difference really is chalk & cheese.


As the batteries for my cordless drill died (see above) I bought a new drill, battery & charger from Lidl. I have bought a few other tools in their range including a battery chainsaw. I know that you saw that don't want one of these. My point is that the Li-ion batteries from Lidl last longer on the chainsaw than the B&D batteries did on the Alligator saw.

Any recommendations for chopping branches up to 100 milli?
I would say it depends on the context. Working up a ladder (securely tied on) I use a pruning saw or bow saw with the raker tooth blade.

Cutting down a tree - but this would be more than 100mm - I would use a chainsaw.

Cutting something in an awkward location (including cutting roots in the ground) I would use a reciprocating saw.

Cutting up wood on a saw horse I normally start with a bow saw as I can use it one handed and so don't have to clamp the wood. If there is a lot to do or it is too thick for a bow saw then I would use a reciprocating saw.
 
Back here looking for a power saw.

I did buy one like the one Deluks recommended.
Brilliant for a hand saw, but I'd like something with some power behind it now

I like the idea of the Ryobi kit. In the same vein, I have a load of DeWalt 18V batteries and a charger and some drill drivers and a reciprocating tool.

So, I could buy a DeWalt saw to add to the collection.

Or another brand, of course.

Robin was correct about chainsaws, I am avoiding them, and jj hit the nail on the head; they are a bit scary.

Plus, there's reviews on Screwfix of the DeWalt one that says it leaks oil all the time, which is not encouraging.

There is the B & D Alligator saw, which seems a lot safer, but I haven't met anyone who has got one.

Any recommendations for chopping branches up to 100 milli?

I've used the 18v DeWalt chainsaw, it's not a bad option. It hasn't got the scary power of a petrol chainsaw, and isn't too long and unwieldy, perfect for 100mm stuff, which can be a pain to cut through if it's dead or a particularly hard wood, as many shrubs can be.
I've also had leaky saws, not a bad idea to syringe out the oil and put it back in the bottle, if you aren't using it regularly, and store the tool on a tray of some sort with an old towel or newspaper underneath.

Second best to that is the 'safety' version with the protected tip. Dewalt DCMPS520N

Other brands have a hinged blade guard at the top. Although it could be argued that these safety features invite complacency.
 

If you need to find a tradesperson to get your job done, please try our local search below, or if you are doing it yourself you can find suppliers local to you.

Select the supplier or trade you require, enter your location to begin your search.


Are you a trade or supplier? You can create your listing free at DIYnot Local

 
Back
Top