have to replace combi-which to buy-Vokera he28, Worcester or

[mery]

hiya,
first i've been very silly, i posted this topic in the electrician section by mistake!
so now i realise that and i dont know if i can transfer it over here in plumbing, i decided to write it all over again!
finally my hubby says we have to replace the broken combi, and i would like to choose one of these 3 combis.
Vokera 28 he,
Worcester Greenstar 28i junior
Vaillant eco tec pro 28.
i personally think to go for the vokera , but i would like to see your opinions about which one you think its better than others.
many thanks

 

[Mark Br]

Why do you want the Vokera?, I'd go with the Vaillant out of the 3, what does your installer recommend

 

[picasso]

my personal choice would be the vaillant ecotec but every installer has their favourite.

 

[mery]

installer recommended vokera but didnt tell me exact model. my friend have this vokera and as they are happy with it i thought it would be sensible. because i've had very bad luck with ferroli.

Why do you want the Vokera?, I'd go with the Vaillant out of the 3, what does your installer recommend

 

[transam]

Out of the 3 go for the Vaillant , stainless steel heat exc !

worc is ally !

Dunno what the Vokera is ?

 

[Whitespirit66]

because i've had very bad luck with ferroli.

Hmmm. Bad luck comes as standard with Ferrolis.

You've probably never heard of them, but for a quality boiler, without a quality price tag, Broag (Remeha) should be on your list.

 

[boilerdoktor]

personally i'd go for the worcester, good reliable product, 5 year guarantee ( if fitted by a worcester approved installer) wouldn't touch a vokera with a barge pole...be warned!!

Vaillant are ok but not the best to work on afterwards ( in my opinion)

 

[Boilerman2]

Speaking as a Service Engineer I'd rather work on the Vaillant any day Worcester are not service engineer friendly!!

P.S. I would agree with the previous comment aboput the Broag Remeha every bit as good as the Vaillant and much better price and 5Yr warranty
my boiler of choice!

 

[Mark Br]

I would go with Whitespirit66 & Boilerman with a Remeha. If you are looking for slightly cheaper still then a Main 30HE.

I also agree with the comments on WB, Would much rather service a Vaillant any day.

 

[onlyfitidealboilers]

you wont go wrong with a ideal logic plus 5 year warrenty.

these boilers would be £300 more expensive if it wasn't for response isar/icos destroying there rep

 

[greemyamochop]

Sorry to butt in guys, were worcester AI just wondered was what good about the Broag, not seen any in this part of the world

Ta

 

[roguetrader]

you wont go wrong with a ideal logic plus 5 year warrenty.

these boilers would be £300 more expensive if it wasn't for response isar/icos destroying there rep

comedy at its best. i p1ssed myself at that one.

 

[onlyfitidealboilers]

What are you on about ?

 

[greemyamochop]

I think he means all ideal boilers are ****e mate

 

[kevplumb]

personally i'd go for the worcester, good reliable product, 5 year guarantee ( if fitted by a worcester approved installer) wouldn't touch a vokera with a barge pole...be warned!!

Vaillant are ok but not the best to work on afterwards ( in my opinion)

oh yeah and worcseter are