The quick fix has been described several times. Get the return temperature below 57C, and ideally the flow temperature also. This is the way to get maximum condensing inside the boiler. We already know that the temperature differential in your system is quite low so you'll need to drop the flow temperature right down to 57C or as close to it as you can stand. With legacy radiators, your house will take longer to warm up so put the heating on a little earlier. People often say their house won't heat up at these low flow temperatures, but what they usually mean is just that their house won't heat up as fast as they're used to.
FWIW, 1,000 pounds for just about heating a five bed house is pretty normal. Short of turning the temperature down more, you aren't going to get any drastic reductions without major outlays (or ditching the CH and huddling round a fire in one room, ahhh, back to the 1960's). Particularly if it is just you in the house, the old cliche of two jumpers is a good one - and of course turn the thermostat down.
P.S. There has been some discussion on the condensing temperature depending on all sorts of things like humidity and air pressure. All this is pretty much irrelevant. The mix of gases passing over the heat exchanger is CO2 and water resulting from combustion (small traces of oxygen, CO) in fairly fixed proportions. The dewpoint of this combination is always near 57C, based on the standard fuel/air ratio used in gas boilers.