Physics Question
- Thread starter UriBentMySpoon
- Start date
Sponsored Links
- Joined
- 28 Oct 2005
- Messages
- 31,282
- Reaction score
- 1,998
- Country
Your question was about something that CANNOT happen in our universe - ever.
It is an impossible question and as such (according to the laws of science) must have an impossible answer.
Give me an example of an impossible question that has a possible solution (he won't).
So why did you give such a definitive answer early on then Joey?Your question was about something that CANNOT happen in our universe - ever.
It is an impossible question and as such (according to the laws of science) must have an impossible answer.
Give me an example of an impossible question that has a possible solution (he won't).
You seemed pretty sure in the beginning of the thread.
Sponsored Links
Oh dear Joe.
Question dodging again.
As the question is impossible then it demands an impossible answer? Ho hum, you are stretching a bit.
So the answer could equally be the Earth keeps orbiting a missing gravity distortion? Its impossible but is allowed in the context of the question?
Here is answer to one of your questions stating no mass, no gravity.
Gravity and light share the same speed, the light we receive is from a moving object, the sun is no longer in the position we see it, same as the gravity, the gravity and light is from an object that is no longer there because of the time it takes to reach us. The sun has scarpered 8 1/2 minutes down the road as it were.
Anyway Joe, how about an answer from you?
What is the speed of gravity? Is it instant or does it travel at the speed of light?
You have a brain that works things out? Use it for once.
Question dodging again.
As the question is impossible then it demands an impossible answer? Ho hum, you are stretching a bit.
So the answer could equally be the Earth keeps orbiting a missing gravity distortion? Its impossible but is allowed in the context of the question?
Here is answer to one of your questions stating no mass, no gravity.
Gravity and light share the same speed, the light we receive is from a moving object, the sun is no longer in the position we see it, same as the gravity, the gravity and light is from an object that is no longer there because of the time it takes to reach us. The sun has scarpered 8 1/2 minutes down the road as it were.
Anyway Joe, how about an answer from you?
What is the speed of gravity? Is it instant or does it travel at the speed of light?
You have a brain that works things out? Use it for once.
- Joined
- 28 Oct 2005
- Messages
- 31,282
- Reaction score
- 1,998
- Country
I'm answering the original question - the reason for the thread.
An impossible question, must by its very nature have an answer that is equally impossible. Therefore, whatever answer you have given so far - is wrong.
I don't know whether gravity travels at light speed or if it travels at all.
You tell me where the sun or your body generates its gravity from and we'll talk.
An impossible question, must by its very nature have an answer that is equally impossible. Therefore, whatever answer you have given so far - is wrong.
I don't know whether gravity travels at light speed or if it travels at all.
You tell me where the sun or your body generates its gravity from and we'll talk.
C
calorific
Not sure about that, but I can help by telling you precisely what you are talking out of
Hmm. Theory of relativity, plus links I have given show, to our current understanding at least, gravity travels at speed of light. Given that Joe, should the Sun gravitational distortion dramatically change, how soon would we on Earth notice it?
Answer a direct question Joe (he won't. FFS Geddit yet etc etc etc)[/i]
- Joined
- 28 Oct 2005
- Messages
- 31,282
- Reaction score
- 1,998
- Country
I'm answering the question that you set. If you want the answer to a different question then start a new thread.
What we do know is that the question in this thread will have an answer that is impossible in our universe - ergo - you are wrong.
What we do know is that the question in this thread will have an answer that is impossible in our universe - ergo - you are wrong.
I have asked you other questions since and you have dodged. Not like you Joe?
I have shown links to show the correct answer to my question which you are ignoring.
You are taking the question in the most literal and pedantic way and twisting the meaning to show you are right. When you are wrong.
Stop wriggling Joe.
I have shown links to show the correct answer to my question which you are ignoring.
You are taking the question in the most literal and pedantic way and twisting the meaning to show you are right. When you are wrong.
Stop wriggling Joe.
- Joined
- 11 Jan 2004
- Messages
- 42,795
- Reaction score
- 2,648
- Country
Did he?
Your name should be Roger, not joe.
Your name should be Roger, not joe.
- Joined
- 28 Oct 2005
- Messages
- 31,282
- Reaction score
- 1,998
- Country
Yes he did. He postulated a question that is impossible in this universe and then supposedly proved it with a solution that is possible. It doesn't work like that. Impossible questions must have impossible answers. If you think that's wrong - give an example. (He won't).
C
calorific
Here's one: "Do impossible answers imply impossible questions?"Yes he did. He postulated a question that is impossible in this universe and then supposedly proved it with a solution that is possible. It doesn't work like that. Impossible questions must have impossible answers. If you think that's wrong - give an example. (He won't).
Sponsored Links
