Woman and Sex, means biological sex.

[JohnD]

transgender self identified

People who are men but want to be women, mostly.

Some women who want to be men.

I hope you are not going to pretend that these are people with physical abnormalities.

 

[Deleted member 323070]

Thought you would be more understanding of him identifying. as a dog rather than insulting him. You seem pretty keen to defend trans women.

If koolpc wants to identify as a dog, I'm comfortable with that.
Here shep!

I'm keen to defend anyone who is under-represented.
I would have though the would be your raison d'etre, to defend those who need defending against discrimination.

 

[Deleted member 323070]

Not as much as men dressing as women who desire to have their genitals chopped off!!!!

The dog resorts to dog whistles.

 

[Koolpc]

If koolpc wants to identify as a dog, I'm comfortable with that.
Here shep!

I'm keen to defend anyone who is under-represented.
I would have though the would be your raison d'etre, to defend those who need defending against discrimination.

Woof!!!

 

[Deleted member 323070]

No it is just a hunch.

No qualifications other than an over-estimate of your hunches, then?

 

[Koolpc]

The dog resorts to dog whistles.

Some do, some dont...

 

[Koolpc]

I know a woman who has gone through the process of having her breasts removed and taking drugs so that she can grow a beard etc.

She wants to have an op down below too....

Thing is, she an extremely disturbed person. A drug addict now too. Totally unhinged. Her life has been turned upside down.

You cannot tell me that she is mentally stable.

I truly believe that anyone who wants to try and change the sex they were born with (which is impossible) are mentally ill....

 

[Deleted member 323070]

If women had a right to single-sex spaces, it would not be necessary to bring religion into it.

They do, so it isn't.

Strange that you think you know what goes on inside his head.

How do you do that?

Your presentation of his argument was wrong.
That was the essence of the discussion:

Your approach is founded on your belief that women do not have a right to single-sex spaces.

If they do, then no religion is required.

If you had understood his argument, you wouldn't have incorrectly paraphrased it. Unless that was intentional.
Was it?
Did you try to have the argument that you wanted, rather than address the argument that morqthana presented?

 

[Deleted member 323070]

Obviously you mix the two up. But it usually starts off being a drag queen sliding down the slippery slope of deciding they prefer womens clothes 24/7...and wanting implants and their tackle cut off!!

I bow to your experience of drag queens.
Is it genuine, or imagined?

 

[Deleted member 323070]

Since these are not Trans people, it is obviously a point for a different discussion.

Of course they are. If their sex is incorrectly assigned and recorderded at birth, and they desire to live their lives in a different gender, they re transgender.

What did you think transgender is?

 

[Deleted member 323070]

Do you respond to wolf whistles when you go out dressed in your mums clothes?

Yo are demonstrating your intellectual ability, and it isn't benefiting your argument.

 

[Deleted member 323070]

People who are men but want to be women, mostly.

Some women who want to be men.

I hope you are not going to pretend that these are people with physical abnormalities.

Have you studied the 2021 census on which to base your claims?
Or are you snatching at figures and ideas from the ether?

How many of the more than 262,000 transgender population were transmen, and how many were transwomen?

 

[Deleted member 323070]

I know a woman who has gone through the process of having her breasts removed and taking drugs so that she can grow a beard etc.

She wants to have an op down below too....

Thing is, she an extremely disturbed person. A drug addict now too. Totally unhinged. Her life has been turned upside down.

You cannot tell me that she is mentally stable.

I truly believe that anyone who wants to try and change the sex they were born with (which is impossible) are mentally ill....

CArt <-> horse?

Your prejudice has decided the order in which to place the cart and the horse.

 

[Highway Man]

I'm keen to defend anyone who is under-represented.

Self appointed then as I see nobody has asked for your help.

 

[morqthana]

That is your problem, and you appear to be in no hurry to resolve your problem.

He doesn't see it as a problem.

He thinks his position is that of an intelligent, cultured, civilised person. Another of his delusions.